#40unit 2intellectual property rights

Patent

Protecting inventions and novel processes.

5-mark Exam Answer

5-mark answer

A patent grants the owner a 20-year exclusive monopoly on the ideas behind an invention. According to Laudon and Traver, patents are granted by the USPTO for machines, man-made products, compositions of matter, and processing methods, and protect the ideas themselves — unlike copyright, which protects only expression.

  • 1.20-year monopoly on ideas behind an invention
  • 2.Granted by USPTO (created 1812)
  • 3.Four patentable types: machines, products, compositions, processes
  • 4.Three exclusions: laws of nature, natural phenomena, abstract ideas
  • 5.Requirements: new, original, novel, nonobvious, no prior art

A patent grants the owner a 20-year exclusive monopoly on the ideas behind an invention. The congressional intent was to ensure that inventors of new machines, devices, or industrial methods would receive the full rewards of their labor and still make widespread use of the invention possible through licensing. Patents are obtained from the USPTO, created in 1812.

Obtaining a patent is much more difficult and time-consuming than obtaining copyright protection (which is automatic). Patents must be formally applied for, and the granting is determined by Patent Office examiners following rigorous rules. Federal courts decide when patents are valid and when infringement occurs.

Patents are very different from copyrights because patents protect the ideas themselves and not merely the expression of ideas. There are four types of inventions for which patents are granted: machines, man-made products, compositions of matter, and processing methods. The Supreme Court has held that patents extend to 'anything under the sun that is made by man' (Diamond v. Chakrabarty, 1980).

There are three things that cannot be patented: laws of nature, natural phenomena, and abstract ideas. A mathematical algorithm cannot be patented unless it is realised in a tangible machine or process with a useful result. The applicant must show the invention is new, original, novel, nonobvious, and not evident in prior art. The danger of patents is that they stifle competition by raising barriers to entry.

Amazon's one-click purchasing patent forced Barnes & Noble to invent a two-click method to avoid infringement — illustrating how patents protect ideas (not just expression) and how they can both encourage and stifle innovation.

A patent grants a 20-year monopoly on the ideas behind an invention (machines, products, compositions, processes), granted by the USPTO, with exclusions for laws of nature, natural phenomena, and abstract ideas.

patent20 yearsUSPTOnonobviousprior artmathematical algorithm exception

The exam interface follows the university paper pattern: Section A & B carry 5-mark questions; Section C carries objective questions.